Proof
Can a fast trader pick off Omnibook’s makers? Every trade goes through a sealed one-second round and a half-second speed bump, so a taker who sees the price move first shouldn’t be able to trade on it. These are the exchange’s own fills, measured after the fact.
Loading the numbers.
Takers’ result 30 s after the fill
–
Trades right after a move their way
–
Fast trades held back
–
Bitcoin 1-minute Up + Down
–
No fills in this window yet. The numbers fill in as people and agents trade.
What a fill was worth to the taker, over time
Per $1 of payout, from the fill to 5 minutes after it. Below zero, makers kept the spread; above zero, the taker gained on the maker. After a trade ends, its settlement value.
By how the trade filled and who took it
The taker’s result per $1 of payout, ± one standard error. Fills counted at each horizon in grey.
Fast trades
Fills split by what the official price did in the 2 seconds before them, in standard deviations of a 2-second move. A taker who reads a faster venue trades right after such moves.
By market
What the numbers mean
- Taker’s result
- What a trade was worth to the person or agent who took the price, against what they paid, per $1 of payout. It’s valued with the exchange’s own pricing model on the official price at each moment, and at its settlement once it ends. A fast trader who could pick makers off would show a positive number at 30 seconds. Fees are left out: takers pay none.
- At the fill
- The spread: the price paid against the model’s fair value at the fill. It’s what a maker earns for quoting.
- Taker class
- Every account starts in A. One whose trades have about broken even moves to B; one that keeps picking makers off moves to C, and makers can quote it wider. The class is the one the account had when it traded. “Unknown” is a fill from before the server last restarted.
- How it filled
- One-tap: a firm quote whose line is set from the first official price at least 0.5 s after the tap. Round: a take at a sealed one-second round close, after the speed bump. Sell-back: selling an open trade back. Auction or offer: an accepted auction quote or offer.
- Makers’ result
- What makers made on settled fills per $1 of payout, before and after the 1% maker fee.
- Lag gate
- While a market’s official price trails its fastest venue, short trades that would gain from the catch-up are held, with nothing charged. The page counts them, and values each as if it had filled at fair value ($0.50 per $1), before any spread, so it shows the most a held take could have made.
- Up + Down
- The best 1-minute Bitcoin Up price plus the best Down price. Buying both pays exactly $1, so what’s over $1 is the makers’ whole spread on the pair.
What this can’t show
- Small samples are noisy. A result within two standard errors of zero isn’t evidence either way, and the page says so. The standard errors treat fills as independent; fills close in time share one price path, so the real uncertainty is larger.
- At the fill, a one-tap is valued on the official price, while its line may include the fastest venue’s lead, so its spread there is approximate.
- The fastest venue’s own prints aren’t kept per fill, so fast trades are measured on the official price.
- The numbers live in the server’s memory. After a restart, fills still in memory (about the last day) are read back without their class.
- Markouts use the exchange’s own model at the market’s reference volatility. Settlement values don’t depend on any model.
Raw numbers (JSON) · Why Omnibook is different · Sealed rounds